Best Men’s Underwear in Canada (2020 Reviews)


Rana Bano

Last Updated:

Beauty
Cansumer is reader-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. This doesn’t influence our evaluations - our opinions are our own. Learn more

Quick overview

Underwear is so much more than just a layer of clothing. Even though they stay hidden most of the time, they have a crucial role to play when it comes to your everyday comfort.

When you‘re successful in finding a pair that provides comfort, support, along with an attractive style, your confidence automatically soars. But you also want something with high durability and a wallet-friendly price tag.

From classic boxer briefs to casual and comfortable boxers, we’ve reviewed the 5 best underwear options for men in Canada, including the best Canadian brand.

Best men’s underwear of 2020

Our research

12

Research Sources

21

Products Evaluated

20k+

Reviews Considered

8

Hours of Research

Best men’s underwear comparison

David ArchyHanes Red LabelFruit of the LoomCalvin KleinSaxx Underwear
Best forOverallBest BoxersBest BriefsBest Boxer BriefsBest Canadian Brand
MaterialBamboo rayon, spandexCotton; Cotton blendCottonCotton, elastanePolyester, spandex
Package of455,8,91, 21
Size RangeS-XXLS-5XLS-5XLS-XLXS-XXL
Colour Options1023715
Total Reviews6,0928,7144,721465702
Aggregate Rating4.44.54.74.54.8

Best overall – David Archy Men’s Boxer Briefs

  • Material: 95% Bamboo rayon, 5% Spandex
  • Package of: 4
  • Size range: S-XXL
  • Colour options: 10

Pros

  • Soft fabric with added stretch
  • Provides you with the maximum comfort possible
  • Minimized friction against the skin
  • Designed to suit all body types

Cons

  • Lower breathability factor
  • Stitching quality needs to be improved
  • Tends to ride up

Size

Available in size S to XL. Some users have found out that the fit tends to be a bit snug. Keeping this in mind, we would recommend you to go for a size bigger if needed. 

Material and durability

The fabric is very breathable due to the 95% bamboo rayon and 5% spandex. It should also be noted that the former material is also nearly 50% more breezy in comparison to cotton.

Bamboo rayon is a cellulosic fibre that is naturally sourced from bamboo. This fabric gives you supreme comfort by boosting air permeability and sweat absorption. At the same time, it’s very durable too.

Now, while the fabric is certainly durable, there is a lot of scope of improvement in terms of stitching. A few customers have found their purchases falling apart due to poor quality stitching, so that’s something that the manufacturer needs to work on.

Style and fit

Having a boxer brief-style, this pair gives you great coverage and support without feeling too restricting.

It has a 3D contour pouch design that makes your package comfortable without feeling too sticky and sweaty. Completing the look is a no-roll waistband that has the logo tape running across. It has a high stretch elastic that feels comfortable against the stomach.

The other thing that we like about these is the flexibility in colour choices. These are designed for everyday wear featuring versatile solid colour options. You can take your pick from 10 choices.

Lifestyle and value

You can easily wear this super comfortable pair all day long! Whether you go to work or hang out at the mall, these will never disappoint you. But, considering the lower stitching, the overall value you get is only decent. But then again, the support and comfort factor makes for some solid plus points.

Best boxers – Hanes Red Label Men’s Knit

  • Material: Solids – 100% Cotton; Heathers – 75% Cotton, 25% Polyester
  • Package of: 5
  • Size Range: S-5XL
  • Colour options: 8

Pros

  • Very comfortable with ultra-soft fabric
  • Classic style with a loose cut
  • Tagless boxers reduce itching
  • Secure waistband that doesn’t dig against the skin

Cons

  • Long length makes it a bit restrictive when wearing pants
  • Thick material may feel warmer for some
  • Inconsistent sizing

Size

This pack of five boxers are available in sizes S-5XL. Although customers have been happy with the sizing, some found out that the size can be a little bigger. Considering these already have a loose cut, this can be an issue when you move. 

Material and durability

If you opt for the solid versions, they are made out of pure cotton. Due to this pure knit construction, the pair feels breathable and gentle after putting it on.

On the other hand, the heathers version has a 75% cotton and 25% polyester blend. This Cotton-rich ComfortSoft® knit has been designed to feel like the softest pair of boxers that you can find.

In terms of durability, the underwear is made to last. One would feel that the knit fabric being so soft, won’t be able to withstand frequent washing, but it stands against all odds and stays as good as new. Also, the stitching is great which only adds to its lasting.

The feel is also quite stretchy ensuring that the pair moves with your body. This minimizes any chance of wear and tear.

Style and fit

Flaunting a classic, loose cut, these boxer-style underwear are a combination of practicality and easy everyday wear versatility. The elasticated waistband features a contrast Hanes repeat logo tape and also gives you a non-binding fit.

These don’t have any tags on them to reduce friction, while the fly has been engineered to never gap. Basically, this pair will keep you comfortable throughout the day making it the go-to underwear option for many men.

Available in basic as well as assorted colours, you can choose according to your personal style.

Lifestyle and value

These are more suitable to be worn under casual wear such as chinos and jeans. The loose fit might feel restrictive when you wear it under suit pants, but nothing that you cannot manage.

We think that these will be worth every penny you spend. The deal is sweetened further with the five-pack offer ensuring you have one fresh for every weekday. 

Best briefs – Fruit of the Loom Men’s Basic

  • Material: 100% Cotton
  • Package of: 4, 8 or 9
  • Size Range: S-5XL
  • Colour Options: 3

Pros

  • Pinch-free leg openings
  • Dual defence protection that helps to keep you dry and smell nice
  • Classic, tagless style

Cons

  • Elastic waistband can feel a little tight
  • Sits loosely on the thighs
  • Nothing fancy on offer for buyers who prefer more colourful patterns

Size

Of course, we are going to put a Fruit of the Loom underwear on our list of the best men’s underwear in Canada! It would’ve been blasphemous otherwise!

You can take your pick from S to 5XL. A few buyers did find the fit to be somewhat large.

Material and durability

These are made out of 100% cotton to ensure a man can wear them on a daily basis without feeling uncomfortable. The material feels incredibly comfortable with a non-binding waistband to keep it firm against your stomach. Even the latter is super comfortable and provides support without digging into the skin.

You get a dual defense protection system with this pair – moisture-wicking and long-lasting odour protection facilities. This system helps to further enhance your comfort that’ll make the underwear your favourite everyday wear set. 

You’ll love the durability of these briefs, for sure! Even after frequent bouts of washing, you won’t find any discolouration, tears, or fading. Complementing the high-quality material is the excellent stitching that keeps the pair looking as good as new.

Style and fit

You get a pair of classic briefs that give you full coverage and pinch-free leg openings. The support shaped fly and full-cut fit reduce any need for constant adjustments all day. It also doesn’t include any tags that would cause any scratching, inflammation or itching problems.

You have three very basic colour options. This, in turn, makes these suitable to be worn on a daily basis. You can take your pick from a full white set, a full off-white set, and an assorted set that features different colours of blue.

Lifestyle and value

If you have a 9-to-5 job or go to college or a school, you would want something that feels like a second skin. The pure cotton fabric along with a fuss-free design of this underwear makes it a perfect match. For full support and complete coverage, we highly recommend this astonishingly comfortable pair.

You can select from a 4-pack set, 8-pack set, and 9-pack set. In our opinion, these are well worth the price and you should certainly add them to your underwear collection.

Best boxer briefs – Calvin Klein Men’s Modern Cotton Stretch

  • Material: 95% Cotton, 5% Elastane
  • Package of: 2
  • Size Range: S-XL
  • Colour Options: 7

Pros

  • Durable and long-lasting fabric and design
  • Suitable for work and home use
  • Form-flattering fit

Cons

  • Tends to become loose at times
  • Some buyers complained of the boxer briefs rolling up their legs
  • Inconsistent fabric quality

Size

These are available from S to XL. Some buyers have found out that these run a size larger, but then again 91% didn’t find any issues. We highly recommend that you check the size chart before you place your order to ensure you don’t end up with the wrong size.

Material and durability

Made with 95% cotton and 5% elastane for added stretch, the fabric is breathable, comfortable, and moves with your body. The only problem here is the inconsistent fabric quality.

Regarding durability, these have a mixed bag of reviews. While a majority of the buyers couldn’t have been more happy with the quality that they received, some found the material to lose shape after frequent washing. 

Style and fit

With the boxer briefs style, you get the best of both worlds. It has an overall relaxed fit to give you good movement. Its length also gives you ample coverage. You can easily team these with skinny jeans or form-fitting pants. There are cases where the underwear might roll up, so make sure that you get the right size. 

Featuring the iconic Calvin Klein logo waistband, you can take your pick from quite a few colours like grey, black, white, navy, and yellow.

Lifestyle and value

The comfortable fabric makes it suitable to be worn on every occasion whether you go to the office or stay home.

Considering the high-quality fabric, brand reputation of CK, and superb reviews, this underwear is unquestionably worth every cent you pay in our opinion.

Best Canadian brand – Saxx Underwear Men’s Boxer Briefs

  • Material: 88% Polyester, 12% Spandex
  • Package of: 1
  • Size Range: XS-XXL
  • Colour Options: 15

Pros

  • Moisture-wicking waistband
  • Provides friction and chafe-free support
  • Seams have reverse stitching to reduce any itching
  • Sculpted fit that keeps you comfortable throughout

Cons

  • Some buyers might find these to be uncomfortable for summers
  • Elastic waistband tends to bend
  • Availability of counterfeits
  • Not exactly meant for daily use

Size – 4

These are available in sizes XS to XXL.

Material and durability

The micromesh fabric is made out of 88% polyester and 12% elastane which makes them perfect for active use. The pin-dot mesh and moisture-wicking material of this pair add to the breathability keeping you cool and dry.

The other advantage of the extremely durable fabric is the anti-odour facility. So, even after you are soaked in sweat, you won’t have to worry about any undesirable smell.

This underwear has a flat seam construction that features reverse stitching. With the softer side of the stitching against your skin, you won’t have to face any itching, chafing, or friction.

It uses high-quality threads which increases the durability considerably. The 5” seam further gives you sufficient space for movement without having the material rip apart.

Style and fit

These are finished with photorealistic prints that are perfect for individuals who aren’t afraid to explore their bold sides. You can choose from a funky fruit print or a colourful candy print. There are also florals, maple leaves, and beer cans!

Cut in a classic boxer briefs shape and slim fit, you get a design that will grab your waist, thighs, and legs comfortably. To be more precise, these have an ergonomic nine-panel construction that gives you 3D support at every angle. 

Every pair of underwear from Saxx has a patented BallPark Pouch that will keep your man-parts in chafe-free comfort and a minimum friction zone all day long.

Lifestyle and value

Another factor to be kept in mind is that these have been designed to keep you comfortable for intense gym sessions. The moisture-wicking fabric along with the snug fit will make sure that the boxer briefs stay exactly where they’re supposed to and hold everything in place.

These are pricey, to say the least. But, if you consider the plethora of advanced tech, and quality of material and craftsmanship, you should surely try them out if your budget permits.

Bottom line

David ArchyHanes Red LabelFruit of the LoomCalvin KleinSaxx Underwear
Size4.64.244.14
Material and Durability4.14.34.44.24.5
Style and Fit4.74.24.24.34.5
Lifestyle and Value4.24.34.34.24.1
Cansumer Rating4.44.34.24.24.3

What to consider when looking for men’s underwear?

Size

If you‘re buying a pair from a different brand then what you normally opt for, you should take a look at their size chart to figure out your size. Assuming that every brand has the same sizing criteria simply isn’t the case.

You can read the customer reviews to figure out whether or not the undergarment runs true to size as well. The other consideration would be to look for shrinkage complaints, and if there is then go a size up.

Material and durability

You’ll be surprised by the material range in which men’s underwear is available. Some of the most common materials include cotton, polyester, nylon, modal, silk, and even antimicrobial fabric.

Cotton is a go-to material for its soft-feel and breathable attributes. Sometimes, cotton underwear comes with added stretch that gives you an even better fit. On the other hand, a polyester material gives you more flexibility and is moisture-wicking that keeps you cool and dry.

Silk, modal, and nylon feel incredibly smooth and soft against the skin, each having their own sets of pros and cons. Some work great for everyday wear, and some not so much. Antimicrobial underwear is a newer innovation that promotes hygiene and minimizes odour in the lower region.

The fabric you choose is also relevant for the support and comfort that you‘ll receive. For example, cotton gives you maximum support whereas, modal is more limited. You can also take into account your living conditions. For example, if you live in cooler weather, you can opt for lycra or flannel-based underwear, while cotton would be more suited for warmer regions. 

Keep an eye out for higher quality and durable fabrics that are less prone to fading and shrinkage issues.

Style and fit

The style and fit of underwear are definitely one of the most elaborate considerations. Boxer shorts, briefs, boxer briefs, and thongs are the four broad categories where you can take your pick from.

Boxers

Boxer shorts are cut in a way to offer little support and are mostly on the loose side which makes them perfect for sleeping or wearing under pleated pants. 

Briefs

Also known as jockey shorts, have minimal coverage and give excellent support that would work best for men who have a 9-to-5 job or love wearing skinny jeans.

Boxer briefs

Boxer briefs combine the best of the above-mentioned underwear styles. They have a snug and supportive fit that suits nearly all body types and clothing choices. 

Thongs

Thongs are certainly not for everybody consisting of thin fabric strips, with bulge-fitting cuts. It’s best suited for men with well-sculpted bodies who’re comfortable in wearing them

After style, you should also consider the colour. From trusty whites and blacks to bold neons and wacky patterns – it all boils down to your personal taste.

Lifestyle and value 

While wearing the same type of underwear daily isn’t wrong, it would just make more sense to have a pair that’s created to suit the different activities you do.

Active/athletic

If you work out or play sports, you should try to buy underwear that can make the activity easier and more comfortable for you. This can include moisture-wicking ability, full support, or any other specialized tech. The only problem with this kind of underwear is that it feels snug which doesn’t make it feasible for everyday office wear. 

Casual/relaxed

Casual or relaxed underwears keep you super comfortable as they have higher breathability. These mostly have loose hems so it doesn’t feel restrictive against the thighs. There might be issues with the support, but it can be made up by getting a pair that has an ergonomic design and seamless stitching.

Sedentary

If you have to sit for extended periods, it’s important to find underwear that won’t have any ill effects on your package. The most prominent one being lower sperm count – avoiding anything that too tight should prevent this.

Formal

For a formal event, you need underpants that go well with a suit without compromising on your comfort. These are generally made out of premium fabrics like modal or silk to give you a streamlined effect. The only downside of it is you can’t wear them on a daily basis.

Always look at your underwear as an investment that can be broken down into cost per wear. The durability is higher for materials that are high-quality and less prone to fading and shrinkage issues. Those that are made out of thinner, cheaper material may seem like a good deal, but don’t pay off in the long run.

FAQs

How often should you wash your underwear?

The only answer to this question is to wash it when it’s dirty. There is no specific timeline or day system that you need to follow for your laundry.

After an intense gym session or playing a sport, your underwear is bound to be sweaty. In such situations, you should watch it immediately because that underwear can lead to bacterial accumulation that may cause skin infections.

We will, however, advise you to wash your underpants after each wear to maintain personal hygiene.

Is there a ‘right’ time to replace your underwear?

A good rule of thumb, when it comes to throwing away one’s underwear, is to replace them at least once a year.

You can also check them to see whether there is any fading, sagginess, cuts or holes, and if you spot any, take it as a sign to discard them. The other tell-tale signs include a loose elastic waistband, stains, or a pair that no longer fits due to weight loss or weight gain.

It’s also important for you to know that your underwear is a clothing item that should never be donated.

How many pairs of underwear should you own?

You should have at least 14 pairs of underwear. The idea here is to have a fresh pair for every day of the week along with backups for travel and exercise. A more sensible approach would be to have a three-week supply that would raise the count to 20 pairs of underwear.

What to read next

Over to you

Do you prefer boxes, briefs or boxer briefs? What is your go-to everyday wear underwear brand? Let us know in the comments below!

Leave a Comment

Know a company that belongs here?

Submit it